A Western Grand Canyon Canyoneering Sampler: SOB (150-Mile), Matkat, and Panameta Canyons

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAOLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA[jump directly to a larger set of photos]

Following our descent of the middle arm of Upper Deer Creek last Fall, Bruce, Bob and I talked about heading down Olo, a canyon that had interested Bob on previous rafting trips.

With input from Todd Martin’s awesome book Grand Canyoneering and excellent advice and beta from Rich, Dave, Dan, Chris, and others (thank you all!), we decided to head down SOB (aka 150-Mile Canyon), cross the river, hit Matkat, Panemeta, and Olo and eventually head back up SOB.

I also planned to do a warm-up trip with a bigger group of friends the week before, taking one of my favorite GC introduction trips, the New Hance to Grandview loop. And so I did. The trip was fun, but threw an interesting wrinkle my way. I got sick as a dog the night before heading down New Hance, and proceeded to sap energy and lose weight through the trip. (Read more about that fun!) OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

Then, right after exiting from the excitement of the warm-up hike, and while while getting ready for part 2, Bob “dorsied” us, letting Bruce and I know that he had to cancel. Our group of three shrank to two (well, two plus Flat Bob, whom Bruce brought along to enjoy the spectacle). Things just got harder. Bob was our Top Gun rope and climbing expert. But more importantly, he was 1/3 of our gear carrying capacity.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAI don’t recall who compared needs of canyoneering in the Grand Canyon to hiking through the desert with scuba gear, but on such a long trip, our already overstuffed packs just got heavier. And depleted from illness the week before, I wasn’t in my usual mule-like state. Nonetheless, Bruce and I decided to plunge ahead, great big packs and all.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAOLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAAfter a night organizing mountains of gear at the trailhead and catching a few ZZZs, we awoke to overcast skies which we eyed suspiciously. The reports had indicated the chance of rain blowing away overnight. But here we were looking at thick clouds and hearing a bit of thunder. Not having been down this drainage, not knowing bail out points, and being none too keen about being caught in a slot during a thunderstorm anywhere in the area, we decided to sit tight for a while and see what happened. In retrospect, we could have hiked a few hours before really worrying too much, but you don’t know what you don’t know. We didn’t know!

As the skies started clearing and the thunder ceased, we headed down sliding through the Coconino and resting when we hit at Buckhorn Spring at the bottom to grab a drink and snap a photo with Flat Bob. OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAWe didn’t realize at the time that Flat Bob would forget his wetsuit in the slot’s pools and decompose, so we were fortunate to catch this image before his demise.

The approach to SOB’s Redwall narrows involves a long walk through the bed of the drainage in the Supai layers. There is a lot of boulder hopping and some pleasant walking on the sandstone.  Eventually, we hit the head of the Redwall narrows and stopped for a snack before jumping in.

Actually, we didn’t jump in. While there is a rappel option that I’d take in the future, OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAwe wanted to make sure we understood the bypass we’d have to take on the hike out so we didn’t have to fart around then. (This, by the way, would have been a good idea at one point lower in the canyon, too! Oh well…) Thus we did a bit of a climb down–a fair amount of exposure, but rock was solid, the holds chunky, and we didn’t feel the need for a belay (although we did lower packs down a short bit near the end).

I’ll leave the primary description of the descent of SOB to Todd’s book. Buy it! There are a few things to add. As with any time you’re in a narrow canyon, you must be mindful of the chance of flooding. As you can see in some of the photos here, a flash of any consequence could be problematic. While there are numerous points during the descent where one can reach higher ground, in some places you are at the mercy of rain which you might not even know is happening.

I’ll also add that in SOB there are plenty of suitable camping locations above the Redwall. And smaller groups can find several safe sites between the head of the Redwall slot and the river to camp or bivy if needed.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAOLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

During the day, it became clear to me that despite the fact that two weeks earlier I’d been near the best canyon shape I’d been in for the past 10 years, the depletion from the week before meant I wasn’t anywhere near 100%. With our late start, and some lolly-gagging just because we were having so much fun (we actually took somewhere near a combined 800 photos on this trip!) we opted to stop well short of the river rather than make a final push.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAOLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

I’m glad we did. This meant we got to see the remainder of the canyon in the growing morning light with fresh legs and fresh eyes. On this first trip down SOB, it was great to look around and soak it in. What’s the rush!

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA We worked our way down the drainage, and made our way to the river, bypassing the Muav narrows so that way could better scout the bypass that we’d need to get back out. On that note, we had a bit of fun with Todd’s description. He says to look for an “unlikely looking ledge on canyon left”. That’s funny. We saw dozens of unlikely looking ledges. Hell, they almost all looked unlikely!  Starting right above the Muav narrows is the right ledge, which Bruce and I decided was the only likely looking ledge. A bit sketchy with some exposure at one bulge in particular (moreso if you happen to be 6’5″ with a big pack), but it goes.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAAnd so we turned out of the drainage and began the trek upriver. The slog is more like it. We didn’t enjoy this 3/4 mile trip to the break which led us down to the river.

Hitting beach, we continued the walk up river until we could go no further. There, we deployed pack rafts and paddled across (and captured it in this too-long video!), and slogged once again up river to a drainage just above the beach known by rafters as Matkat Hotel. (“Why cross the river?” you ask. ‘Cuz that’s where Matkat, Panameta, and Olo canyons are!)

Hitting a small drainage above the Matkat Hotel, what a treat to find the cache left for us a couple of days earlier by Josh on a river rafting trip. (THANK YOU, Josh!)

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAThe next day, given our progress, we decided it was unlikely that we’d spring back and be able to complete the whole itinerary as planned. I hadn’t eaten well in a week, and it was impacting my energy. So, we opted then and there to drop Olo, and save it for another trip. (We did return in the Fall to visit Olo–good thing, too, because Olo is amazing!)

This meant that we had an easy middle day just hiking up and exploring Matkat narrows (aka “Stem City”) and scoping out the trail for a loop through Panameta the next day. It was fun, relaxing, and all things considered a good decision on this foray. And it gave us the chance to make a butt dam with, and accept a couple of beers, from a rafting party.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAAfter a nice restful day we were up early to tackle Panameta canyon. First, this involved a long hike up Matkat. That hike alone was worth the price of admission. It’s not technical, but I really like the bouldering, minor problem-solving, and rock hopping up canyon. From the river to the cut off took a few hours, the last of which we again had fun with Todd’s beta. Rather than the unlikely ledges of a couple days earlier, we were now looking for an “obvious break”. Of course “obvious” is relative, relative to the last break. Fortunately, perhaps, we discounted the first few obvious breaks, and went up a nice looking one where, after heading uphill a couple hundred feet, we saw a couple cairns and then those wily burro trails.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAAn open question for the time being is whether we took the best burro trail–we went a bit on the low side and spent a LONG time contouring around trying to reach the head of Panameta.  I suspect there’s a shorter route up high avoiding many of the smaller drainages. Anyone know the short way?

Eventually, though, we made it to the head of Panameta. Dropping down, we were quickly confronted with a deep pool, and the perfect opportunity to put on wetsuits and harness up. After spending the mid-day walking through the sun, the pool looked, and was, inviting.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAThe narrows started right away with sliding, scrambling, and down climbing. Beautiful and fun. We  quickly lost direct sunlight, the slot deeper, and the water colder. It wasn’t very long before we were glad for the wetsuits. Being a tall, hard-to-fit guy, it’s hard for me to find the bargin wetsuits, and I was wearing a very good O’Neil 4/3mm suit–and I was happy to be as we progressed. The further we went, the colder that water got. I hadn’t started with gloves on, but on one point, after one of the swims through a deeper pool, the hands almost stopped working, and it was well past time to put them on. With a lighter wetsuit, I’d have turned purple.

Panameta is pretty slot. The swirling polished limestone is sublime. And you’re awake enough from the FREEZING water to notice.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAOLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

For those who like the boulder hopping–I do–Panamenta is still a sweet canyon even after exiting the Redwall narrows. Interestingly, neither Bruce nor I have any pictures of this part of the canyon. But the time we exited, it had been a long day already, we knew we were starting to get tired, and we wanted to make it back to camp at the Matkat Hotel before dark. We didn’t make it. We did, though, make it to the cutoff above the Matkat narrows, and walked the last 30 minutes on a decent trail by headlamp.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAThe next morning brought a deliberately slow start featuring oatmeal and dried pineapple. By deleting Olo, we now had a much easier exit ahead of us, and we settled on a two-day course to get from the beach, across the river downstream, and out SOB. After eating and packing up, the day began with a relaxing float down to the mouth of SOB, just above Upset Rapids.

Deciding that since we didn’t need wetsuits on the way down SOB, we wouldn’t need them on the way up, we laid out all the river crossing gear to dry and scouted the cliff climb (since we hadn’t come down the cliff on the way in–we’d stay higher on the ledge to walk up river).

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAAs luck would have it, as we were packing up, a rafting party pulled in to scout Upset. A couple of crazy guys with micro rafts and paddles caught their interest, and we struck up a quick conversation. They were down a spare kayak paddle. We had a spare kayak paddle. They had the ability to carry some extra weight. We had some extra rye (and good rye at that) that we had no intention of finishing on the way up. It was a match made in heaven! The group very generously offered to carry our wetsuits, rafts, paddles, and garbage out for us. (THANK YOU, Carter!)

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

Bruce climbed up the 50′ cliff, bringing a rope and cord so we could fix an anchor, belay Mike, and haul up packs. From there it promised to be a pretty straightforward hike/climb out.  We did stop for the night before the Redwall slot as was our plan. Perhaps the sketchiest part of the trip was climbing up to a ledge to bypass a large pour-off that we’d rapped down just before we stopped. Now, we heard tell of a bypass that starts further downstream. But we missed that start as we climbed up the drainage. Eventually realizing this, but opting not to walk back downstream, I picked a potential route. Bruce asked “where?”.  I said “There!”.  He then asked if I was nuts. It turns out, I was. But we tried it, and sure enough the route went–although it went in a way that I wouldn’t recommend. Next time, we’ll look harder for the easy break up to the bypass!OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAOLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAOLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA

Morning found us up and at it early. We tackled the Redwall narrows, getting up the short-ish up-climbs by ascending ropes in several places that we hoisted into place using parachute cord we’d left behind (another great idea out of Todd’s book). From there it was hopping and scrambling through the Supai, and going up a much easier route through the Coconino than we’d come in on. Apparently we had stayed high too long on our way down. While we followed a trail, cairned in places, it was steep with sliding rocks. In contrast, the way up was gentle switchbacks that provided a smooth steady climb out. Easy on the legs, easy on the lungs, and very little slipping and sliding. Lesson here: through the Coconino on this route, every time you thing the trail cuts up or down, look straight across and you’ll probably find a better way!

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAWe exited, smiled, enjoyed a beer, and got on our way.

I’d be remiss if I didn’t caution you about our dinner stop in St. George at Iggy’s Grill. The beer was bad, the burgers were bad, even the pickle was bad! I intend to be back to SOB. Back not so, Iggy’s!

Cheers,
Mike

(Note, several months later, Bruce and I returned, this time with 3-D Bob. It was a wetter trip, and included a trip down Olo, too!) 

Advertisements

About Mike Rogers

See more on Google+
This entry was posted in Grand Canyon and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to A Western Grand Canyon Canyoneering Sampler: SOB (150-Mile), Matkat, and Panameta Canyons

  1. Kyle Kuns says:

    I don’t have the skills to undertake a journey like that so I really appreciate getting a glimpse.

  2. Tom Conlon says:

    Congrats, you survived! I shudder to think of the risks you guys are taking with the planet’s energy efficiency brain trust… but hey, what’s that Y chromosome for anyway?

    “Man is something to be overcome”. – Nietzsche

  3. Joe says:

    Awesome – Just purchased Todd’s book and are looking at planning an “old guy’s” adventure outing in September. How would you rate these canyons? any difficult pot holes or challenging raps to anchor? Thanks! Joe

    • Mike Rogers says:

      Hi Joe–

      I’d certainly start with Todd’s book. While I teasingly commented on a couple of his descriptions, his beta is very useful. In these canyons, there are seemingly no difficult pot holes (although a couple were swimmers, and who knows what they’d be like without water?). The raps are generally pretty straightforward to anchor. 150-Mile was largely bolted (too bad, because it really didn’t need to be), although a couple bolts are getting long in the tooth. There are a couple of Panameta anchors that you really want to be belayed or tied into a temporary anchor to set–the preferred anchors required significant exposure to either build or inspect. There is one bolt in Panameta that if it weren’t there I think you’d be presented with a real challenge–I couldn’t see how one would build a natural anchor anywhere near the drop. Polished limestone with no real cracks and at the end of a deep pool. A couple of the downclimbs in Panameta are fairly challenging, and the last man (using the last man at risk technique) should be a decent climber (or not afraid to jump 8 ft into a shallow pool). There is some risk to the last man on these!

      [Be careful rigging or building this one, near the end of Panameta: https://plus.google.com/photos/102608569142934368690/albums/5865037400227242849/5865040366280594978 one photo back shows it from the top side.]

      In terms of time, I’d say you’d be prudent to plan on the longer of Todd’s length ranges. Most people who hike or backpack with me say I go very fast. On a good day, I’d be very hard pressed to meet Todd’s low-end estimate. Most people I know would be hard pressed to meet even his longer time range. To gain a better sense and help you calibrate Todd time to your time, you might consider taking a couple of the less technical routes in his book. Matkat Hotel to Panameta and back is a long day for sure.

      In addition to Todd’s book, you can google the relevant canyons and find a handful of helpful trip reports to augment the descriptions and the difficulty estimates.

      Good luck!

      • Joe says:

        Mike – thanks for the feedback!
        Trip time does vary – when going out with the 16yr old cross country running son – we move quite fast, when it is the “old” guys we definitely spend more time enjoying the surroundings. Sounds like having a bolt kit as a very, very last resort is a good idea. Any route suggestions for 3 guys with strong water skills (all live at ocean, lifeguarding, surf, etc) and solid 3A/3B+ canyon experience looking for 3/4 day adventure? Appreciate any feedback

      • Mike Rogers says:

        Hey Joe–down 150-Mile, around Panemeta, and back up would be an awesome trip. However, I’d recommend at least 5 days, especially on the first time through, and crossing the river means the extra weight/volume of packrafts/paddles/PDF. I suggest taking a look at the Middle Arm of Upper Deer Creek, described in Todd’s book and here: https://mikeshikes.wordpress.com/2012/10/13/deer-creek-thunder-river-loop-with-a-descent-of-upper-deer-creek/. I really wanted to see Thunder River, too, and the original plan had called for a decent of Deer Creek Falls at the river (now prohibited by NPS), but the trip could be shortened to 3-4 days. This is an amazing slot and a loop from Bill Hall trailhead would include some beautiful Esplanade walking at the beginning and end. To be safe, you want to allow 5+ hours to get through the slot (or more, depending on speed). You don’t want to be caught in here–no good bailout or camping options. With an early start from the trailhead, you can do it in a day. Then finish Upper Deer Creek and check out the patio and Deer Creek Falls at the river. Hiking up the 3rd day. With a later start, you could also take Day 1 to the start of the Redwall and give yourself a margin to get through the slot. I believe you’d find water before the slot, above the Redwall. This is definitely one worth visiting!

      • Joe says:

        Mike – thanks for the advice, just got Todd’s book over the weekend. Deer Creek looks like a good one if we can get a permit for Sept. Was also looking at Cove Canyon as well. However, the backcountry office stressed that it could still be blazing hot in mid Sept for that particular route. 150 mile canyon is definitely getting added to the list, just don’t have 5-6 days right now.

      • Mike Rogers says:

        The Deer Creek route described will also be hot in mid-Sept (although the middle arm redwall won’t be–nice cold pools that you’ll want a wetsuit for!). But it can be broken down into nice bite-sized morsels with water. Cut it into 4 days and you can avoid hiking in the worst of the heat. The trick here will be leaving the Deer Creek campsites very early so you can get back above the redwall and across much of the Esplanade before it gets too late/hot.

        150-Mile can be done by itself to the river and back in 3-4 days. It’s the stuff on the other side of the river that would add a lot of time. 4 days would give you plenty of time and could be done without full-day slogs through the full sun. I personally wouldn’t take a wetsuit in early Sept (but you might get chilled depending on actual air/water temps).

        Good luck!

        Updated comment: We went down 150-Mile again this October, and we were very glad to have the wetsuits on. Lot’s of water in 150–it was cold and wet! See https://mikeshikes.wordpress.com/2013/10/09/this-time-olo-too/ for more.

What do you think? Feel free to comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s